Amy Paul - Testimonials

Tell Us Your Story

Amy was great to work with.

Before listing our house, she let us know everything we need to do to our house to impress buyers. Amy was always very responsive, which I really appreciated. She always followed up with the buyer realtor after a showing, to get feedback. I would highly recommend Amy to anyone!


Amy is a fantastic realtor and worked hard to find us our dream home.

My family and friends that have used her feel the same way and we will continue to us Amy for all of our reality needs. With Amy you don't just get a realtor but a friend in the end. Honest and true to her work and clients.


Amy Paul did an amazing job.

As a first time home buyer, she made sure that I had all the information that I needed. This was a big decision and, I never once felt rushed or pressure to make a decision. Amy did an amazing job and, I would highly recommend her to anyone that asks.


Amy is exactly what you want in a real estate agent.

She's very clear and transparent about the process, extremely knowledgeable, and great with details. Her attention to detail and recommendations make you very confident in your decisions, whether buying or selling your home. All this with no pushy sales. She spent 6 months helping us find the perfect house, and sold our other home in 2 days! Doesn't get any better than that!


If you are looking for someone who will do what they say, then do it very well, and give you every ounce of her hard working attitude along the way then you will absolutely not be disappointed.


Amy actually really listen to what my wants were and then delivered.

The market was hot but she stayed on top of all things. She was always just a text away. I appreciate what she did for my family and myself so much. She knows her stuff!!


From day one Amy was great to work with!

Living three hours away from the property you are selling can be hard for both the seller and realtor but Amy made the entire process super easy and manageable. Amy always had our best interest in mind. We can't thank her enough for the great service she provided and we can't recommend her enough! 20 days from putting the house on the market to closing!


Amy is amazing!

She’s extremely responsive any time you contact her. Extremely knowledgeable with any questions you might have. She’s professional but friendly, fun, and honest. She’s a great realtor and I believe she truly cares about her clients and does her best to accomplish their visions.


Thank you for everything you did to help us find our home!

This process was very intimidating and overwhelming and we can't thank you enough for being so patient and responsive to all our emails, texts and calls! We can't wait to start our family in this home and that wouldn't have been possible without all your hard work!

Tara & Jason

Amy is the best.

We bought our house from her in 2014. She went through a lot with us to make that happen. So when my husband was being transferred to Indianapolis, we immediately called her to sell our house. She helped to make it happen very quickly and with no stress. She helped price our house at the right point to move it quickly. And when we had multiple offers she helped us decide on the best one. We would use Amy again and again.


Amy is a an excellent Realtor.

We original original met Amy when she help us find and buy our current home 6 years ago. And now she helped us sell our home. She is very knowledgeable about the whole process and fought for us every step of the way selling our house. She is wonderful, and would use her no matter what I was doing; selling or buying.


Amy Paul was amazing!

I never experienced such great help with her! Amy has a lot of knowledge and experience! Amy also helped me try to find appliances that I can get for the house and went up and beyond for me. I never felt so satisfied by getting help with anything. Amy made dreams come true!


Amy is wonderful in every way, her eye for detail (she saw a brick veneer separating from a house we were interested in-saving us $15k repair bill), her marketing and staging expertise were fantastic, she had useful data-driven area-specific information for us when we were debating offer prices.

She had suggestions on which small projects we should complete before listing our house to get the best ROI. We bought our new house and sold old previous home with her, and will use her again in a heartbeat. Post-purchase Amy has been extremely helpful in recommending good companies to accomplish work on our new house. You should hire Amy asap.

Alexis & Joe

Amy was a god send.

I live out of state and needed someone with good communication skills to help my dad and I through the process of selling my house in Ohio. She went above and beyond in keeping both my dad and I updated. She helped find reliable contractors for repairs and updates and helped us understand the process as bids came in. I can not recommend her enough.

Teresa Jester

I have been Dealing with Amy for 6 plus years now I would never deal with anyone but Her.

She has found me homes to buy and has just Sold another for me. She is the most responsive Agent I have ever dealt with. If your looking to Buy or Sell Amy (Pape) Paul is a great agent!


Super nice super easy to work with we practically had to do nothing but look at houses she took care of everything.

She listens to what you want in a house and finds it. Would recommend to anyone and if I need to buy another house will use her again.


When finding a place for my family I wanted a realtor that I could trust and count on, that's why I called Amy.

She is extremely knowledgeable and will go to bat for her clients. Amy has helped us in the past and I knew we could count on her for our new search. She helped us pick the perfect home and my family and I couldn't be happier. Amy will never know the true happiness she has brought to my family and allowed for all the new memories that will come. Thank you Amy.


Amy was great to work with.

She brought a lot of experience and had a nice marketing plan. She was great with communication, especially considering that I was out of state for most of the process. She was very patient and accurate when answering any questions I had, and was always available when I needed her help.


Amy was wonderful to work with, she was always there to answer any questions we had.

I would highly recommend her. Amy made the home selling/buying experience fun and enjoyable.


Thank you for all you've done for us over the last 5 months, we couldn't have done it without you.

We're happy to have gained a wonderful friendship throughout our buying & selling adventure. Here's to a new chapter in our lives and many new memories to come.


Amy Paul is a tenacious go getter who was always finding solutions to problems which hadn’t come up yet.

I was unsure of which colors to paint the rooms. Her recommendations look great. We had several showings which generated multiple offers. She is the definition of hard work, tenacity and professional. If you are looking for a fantastic realtor, call Amy!!


Amy was always there when we needed her, and when things did go array she quickly stepped in for us, and she did that because she does have great concern for her buyers!

! She will find you your right home!!!


Amy was Excellent from day 1!

She was always very responsive and available to talk when we needed her. Highly recommend!


What can I say about Amy that I’m sure has not been said a hundred times before but I will try.

Amy made me laugh many times during this stressful event. We purchased a house before even having ours ready to sell. Scary right! Amy’s knowledge of the market was crazy on point. Amy even tried to help me talk my wife out of buying and selling even though she knew I was going to fail! Why? My wife is always right. I love our new home and I am so glad she failed. I would recommend Amy to anyone and everyone I know and don’t know. Thank you Amy for all that you did for us!!


Amy was very patient with my 2 year long search for the right home.

Her knowledge far exceeds any other realtor I had worked with, and she always has a smile on her face. I consider her an expert in the real estate market.


Amy has gone above and beyond what was expected to sell my home.

I sold my condo all while living in Chicago and never once made a trip back to Columbus. She helped hire and manage all contractors for the small renovation projects, staging, photography, cleaning, etc. Her communication was thorough and prompt. Also, let's not forget she exceeded my expectations on the sale price! I am so grateful to have worked with her and her team -- I would highly recommend her services.Thank you Amy for all of your hardwork and thoroughness in completing the sale of my condo!


Amy is seriously so awesome.

Probably won't even look for another realtor as long as she is in the field. She is trustworthy, honest, polite and, overall, just a great person who has your back.


Amy is the best when it comes to real estate.

She really knows her stuff and and is wonderful at keeping you in the loop. She never lets any matter sneak by the buyer and makes sure to constantly update. If you’re a first time home buyer I would highly recommend her as she will guide you through the process and leave no stone unturned. If you go with Amy you will feel as though you know the business in and out. She always makes sure to make the time for you and your needs. If you’re ready to look at a house just give her a call, text or email and you’ll be be doing your walkthrough before you know it. If you’re not going with e-Merge and you haven’t hired Amy, you’re doing it wrong.


I bought my first house with Amy in 2006.

She was so nice, knowledgeable and easy to work with! She has helped many friends and family members since then and we also just sold my original home and purchased another. I recommend Amy to everyone!


Amy really understands the real estate business!

She knowledgeable and very responsive, and really cares about making sure clients make a great decision. She provided a lot of great information from day one about the home buying process. Amy is straight forward but never made us feel pressured. I’ve worked with other agents so I know she goes the extra mile to support her clients. Amy gets straight to business during showings and clearly communicates things you should be aware of or items that could be easily overlooked. She can tell you on the spot ways to improve a space or things that you should update to keep a home safe and structurally sound over time. Amy is a great advocate for buyers which is rare in this market! She lived up to her reputation of being an energetic, efficient, and experienced realtor. We highly recommend her for first time buyers, transitioning buyers, or investors based on her skills and extensive referral network. I would definitely work with her again and have already recommended her to family and friends!


Amy was persistent in her efforts to show and sell our condo.

She even did some work in the condo to improve its presentation because we live 2 1/2 hours away. She did some minor repairs, painting and cleaning. She also was able to recommend reliable sources for other repairs. Amy communicated via ph, text, and email to keep us abreast of the showings and responses. The bottom line is she never gave up despite difficulty with interested parties financing, and the end result was a sale that we accepted.


Amy was great!

She worked with us for over a year to find the perfect house. Once we finally did she was able to sell our house in just a few days. She helped us get a great price and we could not be happier.


We used Amy to help us find and purchase our first home.

She helped us navigate all the paperwork and understood the intricacies of using a VA loan. We took a while finding our home, but Amy never showed anything but enthusiasm when showing us houses. She also has a good eye for identifying potential concerns in a home and discussed those with us. We never once felt pressured to "hurry" or "settle" on a home. Ultimately the best review that I can give for Amy is that I recommend her to anyone I talk to looking for a home and we will be calling her when we are ready to find a new home.


Thank you for all you've done for me over the past few months!

I distinctly remember a moment in which you said to me, "You can't give up! We will find you the right one!" You were always encouraging & made the process stress-free by keeping me laughing. I know you went the extra mile so my daughter can enjoy her last three years at Thomas Worthington which was so important to me. Many, many thanks and I will continue to sing your praises to potential house hunters and sellers.


Amy helped us purchase our new home.

She was knowledgeable and helpful with any questions we had. She was always on top of everything and quick to get us answers. I highly recommend Amy to help you find your next home.


As out of town buyers, Amy was very responsive and attentive to our needs.

She was knowledgeable and honest with her evaluation of the homes shown. She went the extra steps to make sure we were confident during the process!



THANK YOU! I couldn't have done this without you! Thanks for showing me all the houses and helping me by answering all my questions.


Amy is on top of it all from beginning to end!

If you need a real estate agent, she's the one!! Whether you are looking to buy or hoping to sell, Amy will guide you through the process with ease. She was very helpful and responds timely. She helped us with staging and answered all of our questions prior to listing. She knew exactly what buyers want and what needed to be done. The brochures and photos were top quality. The online listing was marketed through many sites and had numerous views. Amy was on top of every detail. It was a quick and worry-free sale. Everything was seamless throughout the entire process.


Absolutely wonderful, always kept in touch did a fabulous job.

Extremely knowledgeable of local market. Condo sold first day on market. Will continue to refer her to family, neighbors and friends.


Thank you for your kindness, guidance, your sense of humor and fun, but most of all-- thank you for being such an amazing knowledgeable resource for our daughter's first home search!

You're outstanding! Her Dad and I are so grateful she had you during this process! God bless you!

The Johnson's

As an out-of-stater looking at homes in the Columbus area, let me say Amy was an absolute life-saver!

Within a half hour of contacting her she had called me back and went right to work looking for our new home. In this market, that is no easy feat - especially with us being 9+ hours away. We relied heavily on Amy's knowledge of the area and she certainly guided us in the right direction as to location, neighborhoods, schools, etc. She took our "wants" in a house seriously and made us feel like a priority. She was understanding, patient and a fighter to get us in our new home. I would absolutely recommend Amy to anyone looking to buy or sell, she most certainly has her client's best interest at heart! THANK YOU, AMY!

The Fedorko's

Amy was great to work with.

Before listing our house, she let us know everything we need to do to our house to impress buyers. Amy was always very responsive, which I really appreciated. She always followed up with the buyer realtor after a showing, to get feedback. I would highly recommend Amy to anyone!


I've used Amy 3 times now, to buy my first house and then to sell and buy a new house.

She's always been great! She really helps me to know what I want, what I need and she is sure to find properties that have those things. She's never once push me over budget but it still managed to make sure you're everything I want and need in the house. Amy's also great Selling Houses. She make sure that the house is visible everywhere it can be, she takes professional photos herself and really knows the market ensuring that the updates that I needed to make to get my house sold at the price I wanted weren't excessive but we're very effective.


Amy was outstanding in every aspect of my home purchase, from start to finish.

She is patient, knowledgeable, accessible and genuine. At no point in my home search did I ever get the feeling she was there "for the sale." She wanted to honestly know what I needed, what I wanted and tried to help any way she could. When my mortgage numbers were going through, she was in communication with them and myself constantly, and when an error occurred, she was on them relentlessly until it was corrected. I feel more that she is a friend than my realtor, and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy. As a first time buyer, I was uneducated and sometimes intimidated by the numbers, jargon and pace. She explained everything clearly and concisely, and never let me down knowing that my needs for a home were the highest priority.


Amy is simply amazing!

She responds lightening fast and pays attention to the smallest detail! Amy sold my house in Sept of 2015 in one day and helped my daughter find the perfect condo this month! I wish this review had 10 stars... not just 5!


Our experience with Amy Paul in selling our home was wonderful.

She was always available 24/7 for us. She was very professional, and went above and beyond in order to get our home sold. I will highly recommend her to all of our friends who wish to sell or buy a home.


We have worked with Amy as both buyers and sellers for the past 15 years.

She is energentic, honest, and extremely knowledgable in the Columbus market. This is our 3rd purchase/sale with Amy and each one has been a positive experience. She's extremely responsive, and does a great job giving advice.

The Penza's

Amy is honest, transparent, and incredibly easy to work with.

She is personable and down to earth. She was diligent in finding homes to tour that fit our specific wants and needs. The market is tough and she kept us encouraged during the whole search. She helped me and my fiancé find our first home and we are so grateful that we worked with her. I recommend her to anyone buying or selling!

The Sheely's

You were absolutely the BEST part of the whole selling/buying experience.

I fully believe if it weren't for you we would still be waiting to complete the sale of our house. You helped us know what to ask about, and you gently prodded what needed kicked. We can't thank you enough for everything you did!


Amy is extremely knowledgeable and very experienced with the real estate market.

She's very resourceful and can track down answers to about anything you need or want to know. Our experience with her was outstanding and we highly recommended her!

Jeannie Tien

I initially met with Amy under the recommendation of a co-worker.

But after that first meeting I knew there was no need to even consider interviewing other brokers. She was friendly, attentive, had immediate ideas of properties to meet my requirements, and made me feel like I was her only client rather than just another cog on an assembly line. I wish you had another category beyond Excellent, especially for the Patient characteristic. I am a "needy" client and Amy never once allowed me to feel like I was pestering her with my questions.


Amy helped me find my first home.

She has a wealth of knowledge and you will be surprised the things she notices. I completely trusted her opinions as an expert and absolutely love my new home. She definitely had my best interest in mind and was not pushy at all. I highly recommend her to anyone.


Amy is an outstanding realtor and advocate.

We have used her across the years in both buying and selling. She’s a star! We highly recommend her! In our most recent out of state relocation, Amy had all the details covered and made the move much less stressful.

The Barbers

Amy was always honest and kept our best intentions in mind when we toured properties with her.

She would respond immediately whenever we reached out with questions about the process and was incredibly patient (we were first-time buyers and super anxious about the 2021 housing market). She was also invaluable in helping us envision our lives in each potential property, pointing out items in need of repair and possible renovation strategies. There wasn't much negotiation to be had, but she always kept us updated and provided any and all info/documentation we asked for. It was an incredibly smooth and stress-free process, which is essential when using a buyer's agent. Highly recommend Amy!


Amy did a wonderful job from start to finish.

She was available 24/7 to answer any of my questions. I cannot thank her enough and will definately use her services in the future.


Professional and Knowledgable!

Amy showed me many houses and condos from 2019 until I found one in 2022! Planning on using her to sell my current home.

The Weimer's

Amy is professional, patient, knowledgeable, and hard-working.

She helped us sell our first home and buy our second home which was a HUD. In a few years we will definitely be using her again to sell and find our dream home. We would recommend her to anyone we know.


Great experience!

She is honest and knowledgeable about the area and market. Our house sold in less than a week. Definitely would recommend to others.


We were very pleased with our first home buying experience with Amy!

She helped us through every step of the way, and was always accessible and knowledgeable. She was able to point out the strengths and weaknesses of each house, and get us help and estimates for needed repairs and renovations. Can't recommend Amy enough!


Amy was recommended to us and I am truly grateful she was the one that helped us through this process.

Since day one, her knowledge and dedication definitely showed. She spend countless hours answering our questions and helping with different issues that arouse during the process, providing insightful data and information during every single step. Her charisma and go-getter attitude definitely put her well above any other realtor that I know. I would highly recommend her to anyone thinking about purchasing a home. Thanks Amy once again for all your support and dedication!


We first met Amy (through a personal friend referral) back in 2014 when we were looking to purchase a condo, and she was fabulous to work with.

We have lived in this condo for 7 years and she has kept in touch through Facebook, Instagram and has consulted with us several times when we have considered selling to upgrade to a single family home. In December 2019 when my parents were relocating from Findlay, Ohio to Hilliard, I connected them with Amy and she helped them find the condo of their dreams! My Dad was going through cancer treatments at the time, and Amy made the process easy for them. When we were finally ready to sell this condo (the one Amy helped us find) and buy a single family home, Amy was incredibly responsive via text and set up a time to come meet with us that week. Here's the thing - Amy is not only knowledgeable and experienced, but she is wonderful at working with people. She did an amazing job at helping us finding a balance between being positive and realistic in which is necessary because selling and buying a home is a stressful and emotional process (especially in this market). She helped us set expectations and keep our sanity! Amy was available to us day and night via text and phone; and even though I know she was juggling multiple clients and her own family/personal life, she always made us feel like we had her full attention. When our condo was up for showing, she used a helpful app (showing time) that made communicating information between us and potential buyers easy. Amy also keeps a cool head under pressure. When our condo first went on the market, the showing time app went a bit haywire and Amy was diligent about not only trouble shooting the problem with the company, but also communicating through phone/text with the realtors of all of the potential buyers. Even with the app down for several hours, we were able to secure 30 showings (!!!!) because of Amy. Amy is honest; she will help you put your best foot forward to make sure your home look amazing in the listing. She gave great advice around how we could prep our home to took perfect in photos and on showing days. She works with an amazing photographer who came with a DRONE and took overhead photos of our property and pool (which is a huge selling point). She really made our place look amazing in the listing (even boosting it on social media). Once we got into contract (within like 3 days of listing), Amy helped us manage our anxiety around the inspection time. When a potential issue came back on the inspection Amy "knew a guy" (newsflash: she has a guy for EVERYTHING LOL) who she was able to arrange right away and he took care of the issue. Amy uses a program called dot loop for all paperwork (there is a lot) which makes reviewing and signing the multiple documents between banks, buyers, sellers, etc. so much less confusing. We really appreciated that, and the fact that it saves the environment from all of that paper! As I'm writing this review it has been less than 6 weeks since the day I texted Amy to tell her we wanted to put our condo on the market ... we closed today, and we will close on our new home in less than 2 weeks. It's absolutely incredible. She will make sure your needs are met and that you are taken care of! Last but not least, Amy is fun to work with. As I mentioned earlier, buying and selling homes is very stressful. When we texted or talked on the phone, even in stressful moments, it was rare that we weren't laughing at some point or sharing funny gifs to express our feelings in the moment. It makes everything so much better when you can have fun. :) So - to sum things up, I give Amy my highest recommendation. She is knowledgeable, professional, well connected, responsive, caring and fun. Thank you Amy!!!!

Katie & Patrick

Amy is a true professional and an excellent negotiator, but more importantly she is one of the most honest people I've ever met.

My wife and I were so pleased with the service she provided when buying our home that we called on her to sell the house when we left Ohio four years later. Because of the great suggestions she made about pricing and upgrades the house sold in just 30 days. (2015)


Amy was well prepared from start to finish.

She came in with everything needed for us to proceed with listing and selling the home. We had a wonderful experience working with Amy and would highly recommend her to anyone who is in the need for a realtor. Not only is she professional she's very personable and always has time to answer your questions. Amy is top notch! I can't say thank you enough for all she did for us.


Amy was excellent to work with.

We found our perfect house. She is very patient and so helpful. She goes above and beyond for her clients. We would definitely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell.


We had a wonderful experience with Amy Paul.

It has been many years since we have purchased a home, so much has changed. Amy did aa wonderful job guiding us through every step of this transaction. Our offer to purchase and many follow up items took place so close to Christmas but Amy was ALWAYS accessible to us. We appreciated her attention to every detail.


Amy helped us with purchasing a new home and selling our existing home.

We found a house we loved and Amy helped negotiate on our behalf. She was looking out for us as the buyers but was also realistic and knowledgeable in the way the market was trending. Amy helped us in preparing our home to put on the market. She was honest on what we needed to do to list the house. She gave some recommendations that we chose not to do. They were all comments that we received from the showings. Amy knows Gahanna well and listed our house in the right price range. We had over 30 showings and sold in under 5 days with multiple offers. Amy is patient, knowledgeable, always checks in and keeps you updated through the whole process. Selling, buying and moving is stressful enough, but Amy keeps you excited about the process. Amy has a great list of resources and experiences and can always answer your questions. Hands down, Amy is the best!


I can't say enough nice things about Amy!

! She exceeded all expectations. She took her time and explained anything I didn't know or understand, and helped me navigate numerous obstacles that arose during the home buying process. She has continued to help me work with the sellers and builders even after the closing. I can't imagine another realtor being as helpful and on top of things as Amy.


Amy is very knowledgeable and professional.

She sold our house in two days. After receiving 14 contracts the first day and 22 the second, We received a contract of 15K more than our asking price. If you want to sell your house really fast and get more than your asking price, call Amy Paul with E-Merge Realtors.

Reviews on Zillow
Average Rating
"Amy is extremely knowledgeable and very experienced with the real estate market. She's very resourceful and can track down answers to about anything you need or want to know. Our experience with her ... more "
by 6c7aatr9wx
"We have worked with Amy as both buyers and sellers for the past 15 years. She is energentic, honest, and extremely knowledgable in the Columbus market. This is our 3rd purchase/sale with Amy and each ... more "
by matthew penza
"Amy is an outstanding realtor and advocate. We have used her across the years in both buying and selling. She’s a star! We highly recommend her! In our most recent out of state relocation, Amy had all ... more "
by samuelsbarber

Property Search